Saleshandy vs Mailshake: Which Cold Outreach Tool Is Superior?

I've run outbound for teams that lived in email, and teams that needed LinkedIn and phone in the same week. Saleshandy, Mailshake, and Salesforge all promise booked meetings, but they are built very differently under the hood.

Saleshandy is an email-first tool with a dialer, WhatsApp, and a lead database. Mailshake is an email-first sales engagement tool that adds a dialer and LinkedIn on its top plan. Salesforge runs email and LinkedIn together and adds an autonomous AI SDR.

The decision I kept facing was simple: buy a cheap email tool and bolt LinkedIn on separately, or run both channels natively. I tested all three. Here is how they actually compare on channels, deliverability, pricing, and scale.

Cold Outreach Tools Compared at a Glance: Saleshandy vs Mailshake

Here is the short version before the detail. Every figure below is pulled from each vendor's live pricing page and the Salesforge knowledge base.

Saleshandy Overview: Email, Dialer, and a Lead Database

Saleshandy is an email outreach platform built for sales teams, recruiters, and agencies. It markets itself as a "multichannel" outbound platform, and the channels are email, a phone dialer, WhatsApp, and a manual task list. Notice what is missing from that list: LinkedIn automation.

It is genuinely strong on raw email volume, and it bundles a lot into each plan.

• Unlimited email accounts on every plan, so your sending cost is the mailboxes themselves.
• High active-prospect and email caps, up to 100,000 prospects and 300,000 emails a month on Scale Plus.
• An AI Sequence Copilot to draft and refine email steps.
• Built-in email warm-up with unlimited warm-up accounts.
• A unified inbox, sender rotation, and an inbox placement test.
• Lead Finder, an 852M+ contact database sold as a separate subscription.
• A dialer add-on for cold calling, plus a CRM and an MCP server.

Pricing

Saleshandy uses flat per-plan pricing, not per seat. Outreach Starter is $36/mo monthly or $25/mo billed annually (2,000 active prospects, 6,000 emails). Outreach Pro is $99/mo monthly or $69/mo annual (30,000 prospects, 150,000 emails). Outreach Scale is $199/mo monthly or $139/mo annual, and Outreach Scale Plus is $299/mo monthly or $209/mo annual. Lead Finder, email verification, and email infrastructure are separate add-ons.

Who it's best for

Saleshandy fits solo senders and agencies that run high-volume cold email and want the lowest cost per send. The unlimited email accounts and large prospect caps make it a sensible pick for pure email programs.

Known limitations

• No LinkedIn automation at all - the "multichannel" story is email, phone, and WhatsApp.
• Lead Finder data is a separate subscription on top of the outreach plan.
• One-time verification and lead credits expire, so the real monthly cost runs higher than the headline.
• No autonomous AI SDR - the AI Copilot drafts copy, it does not run the campaign.

What reviewers say

Saleshandy holds a 4.7/5 on Trustpilot, but the critical reviews are worth reading before you commit. One recurring theme is support response time and how credits are billed.

Mailshake Overview: Email, Dialer, and LinkedIn for Small Teams

Mailshake is a sales engagement platform for small teams and agencies. It launched as a cold email tool and has grown to cover a phone dialer and LinkedIn touches on its higher plan. It is trusted by 100,000+ teams and is known for being simple and fast to set up.

• Email sequences with automated follow-ups based on opens, clicks, and replies.
• SHAKEspeare, an AI email writer, plus an AI Sales Coach.
• A/B testing, email rotation, and a unified inbox on the Email Outreach plan and up.
• A power phone dialer with 5 numbers and unlimited North American dialer minutes on Sales Engagement.
• LinkedIn automation - connection requests, messages, and profile views - on Sales Engagement.
• Lead Catcher to surface your most engaged prospects.
• CRM integrations (Salesforce, Pipedrive, HubSpot) and 1,000+ apps via Zapier.

Pricing

Mailshake charges per user/seat. Starter is $29/mo monthly or $25/mo annual and gives one email address per seat with 1,500 sends a month. Email Outreach is $49/mo monthly or $45/mo annual with two email addresses per seat and unlimited sends. Sales Engagement is $99/mo monthly or $85/mo annual with ten email addresses per seat, plus the dialer and LinkedIn. Data Finder ($19/mo) and Ready to Use Mailboxes ($12/mo) are add-ons, and there is a custom Agency plan.

Who it's best for

Mailshake suits a small team of one to three reps that wants email, phone, and LinkedIn in one simple tool and is fine paying per seat. Setup is quick and the learning curve is short.

Known limitations

• Per-seat pricing and a fixed inbox-per-seat ratio (1, 2, or 10) make scaling expensive.
• LinkedIn and the phone dialer are locked to the $99/mo Sales Engagement plan.
• No free trial - Mailshake collects payment up front and its FAQ states a no-refund posture.
• No autonomous AI SDR - SHAKEspeare writes copy, it does not prospect or run sequences for you.

What reviewers say

Mailshake carries a strong 4.7/5 on G2, and most users like it. The critical reviews tend to cluster on bugs and the refund policy.

Salesforge Overview: Multi-Channel Outreach With an AI SDR

Salesforge is the outreach layer of the Forge Stack. It runs email and LinkedIn sequences from one dashboard, with AI personalization, deliverability protection, and an optional AI SDR. The pitch is one connected system instead of a cheap email tool plus a pile of bolt-ons.

• Multi-channel sequences combining email and LinkedIn in a single workflow.
• Unlimited mailboxes on every plan, and unlimited LinkedIn senders on the Growth plan.
• Free, unlimited premium warm-up through Warmforge, included with every subscription.
• Primebox, a unified inbox that captures email and LinkedIn replies with sentiment tagging.
• Overdrive Mode for multi-source AI personalization that pulls from the prospect's site and posts.
• Agent Frank, an autonomous AI SDR that prospects, writes, follows up, and books meetings.
• Smart mailbox rotation, dynamic IP rotation, and a Knowledge Base for AI replies.
• Native CRM integrations (HubSpot, Salesforce, Pipedrive, Clay), an API, and an MCP server.

The Forge Stack context

Salesforge does not include email infrastructure in the base price. Instead it connects natively to three infrastructure products: Mailforge (shared IPs, $3 to $2 per mailbox), Infraforge (dedicated IPs, $4 to $3 per mailbox), and Primeforge (real Google and Microsoft mailboxes, $4.50 to $3.50 per mailbox). You can also bring your own mailboxes, enrich lists in Leadsforge (500M+ contacts), and warm everything with Warmforge. The whole stack syncs without Zapier in between, which is the part you can even script from the terminal or Claude.

Pricing

Salesforge uses flat plan pricing, not per seat. The Salesforge Pro plan is $48/mo monthly or $40/mo annual (1,000 Active Contacts in sequence, 5,000 emails, 1 LinkedIn sender, 1 user). The Salesforge Growth plan is $96/mo monthly or $80/mo annual and adds 10,000 Active Contacts, 50,000 emails, unlimited LinkedIn senders, unlimited users, A/B testing, multi-language sequences, the API, and ESP Matching. You can verify the live price any time. Agent Frank is a separate subscription from $499/mo billed quarterly ($416/mo annual), and he is not bundled into the Pro or Growth plan.

Who it's best for

Salesforge says it fits B2B teams selling at $5K to $100K ACV into startups, SMBs, and mid-market, targeting 3,000 businesses or more. It is also honest about the other side: Salesforge says it is a poor fit if you primarily sell to Fortune 500 accounts, rely on long RFP cycles, or close a few six- to seven-figure deals a year.

Honest limitations

• Email infrastructure is a separate cost - the base plan does not include mailboxes.
• The API, A/B testing, and ESP Matching are gated to the Growth plan.
• Agent Frank requires a sales-led demo and a 2-week warm-up before he can start sending.

What reviewers say

Salesforge holds a 4.6 on G2, and its Trustpilot reviews are detailed. The one below is from a reviewer who had already tried Saleshandy, Instantly, Apollo, and Smartlead.

See Salesforge
in Action

Start Live Demo Now

Head-to-Head Feature Comparison: Saleshandy vs Mailshake

This is where the three tools split apart. I'll go channel by channel so you see the full picture, not just one headline.

Multi-channel outreach: email, LinkedIn, and phone

This is the clearest gap. Saleshandy has no LinkedIn automation - its channels are email, dialer, and WhatsApp. Mailshake does have LinkedIn, but it sits on the $99/mo Sales Engagement plan alongside the phone dialer. Salesforge runs email and LinkedIn in the same sequence on every plan, with unlimited LinkedIn senders on Growth. If you want to pair email and LinkedIn touches, Salesforge does it natively without a top-tier upgrade or a per-seat charge for each profile.

Email deliverability and warm-up

All three include email warm-up. Saleshandy and Mailshake both bundle unlimited warm-up, which is good. The difference is the pool and the infrastructure. Salesforge's Warmforge uses a curated pool of real Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 mailboxes, with a Heat Score per mailbox and monitoring, and it stays free and unlimited on every plan. On top of that, Salesforge offers three dedicated infrastructure products so you can diversify across shared and private IPs. Saleshandy sells mailboxes as an add-on, and Mailshake offers a "Ready to Use Mailboxes" add-on at $12/mo for five mailboxes per domain.

AI and personalization

Every tool has an AI writer. Saleshandy has its AI Sequence Copilot, and Mailshake has SHAKEspeare plus an AI Sales Coach. Both draft copy, then hand it back to you. Salesforge goes further with Overdrive Mode for multi-source personalization, and then with Agent Frank, an autonomous AI SDR that prospects, writes, sends, follows up, and books meetings on Auto-Pilot or Co-Pilot. Neither Saleshandy nor Mailshake has a real AI SDR - that is a category Salesforge owns in this group.

Inbox management and reply handling

Saleshandy and Mailshake both offer a unified inbox for email replies, and Mailshake adds Lead Catcher to flag hot leads. Salesforge's Primebox goes wider: it unifies email and LinkedIn replies in one view, tags each thread positive, neutral, or negative with sentiment analysis, and can draft replies with Primebox AI on the Growth plan. Because Saleshandy has no LinkedIn and Mailshake has it only on the top plan, their inboxes are email-side by design.

Pricing and scalability

The pricing models matter more than the sticker prices. Mailshake charges per seat, and each seat unlocks a fixed number of inboxes (1, 2, or 10). If your sending strategy needs more inboxes than headcount allows, the cost climbs fast. Saleshandy avoids per-seat pricing and gives high email volume cheaply, which is a real strength for pure email. Salesforge also avoids per-seat pricing, includes unlimited mailboxes on every plan, and adds unlimited LinkedIn senders on Growth, so eight reps can all connect profiles without paying per profile. These are the economics that decide which tool scales with you.

Integrations and infrastructure

All three integrate with the major CRMs (HubSpot, Salesforce, Pipedrive) and Zapier. Saleshandy and Salesforge both ship an MCP server and an API. The structural difference is infrastructure: Salesforge sits inside the Forge Stack with Mailforge, Infraforge, and Primeforge as native infrastructure, plus Leadsforge for data and Warmforge for deliverability. Saleshandy and Mailshake treat infrastructure as a single add-on. That matters because cold email only works when it lands, and diversified infrastructure is how you keep it landing at scale.

Pricing Comparison: What Each Tool Actually Costs

Here is the pricing side by side. Salesforge and Saleshandy use flat per-plan pricing. Mailshake charges per seat, so I've noted that below.

The headline numbers look close at the entry level. Mailshake Starter and Saleshandy Outreach Starter both land at $25/mo billed annually, and Salesforge Pro is $40/mo annual. The gap opens up as you add people and channels.

Here is a real scenario. Say you're a 5-person team that wants email and LinkedIn, sending from 10 mailboxes. On Mailshake Sales Engagement that's 5 seats at $99/mo, so $495/mo ($425/mo annual), and LinkedIn only unlocks at that tier. On Saleshandy you'd pay one Outreach Pro plan at $69/mo annual for the email volume, but you'd get no LinkedIn and would bolt a separate LinkedIn tool on top. On Salesforge Growth it's one flat $80/mo annual ($96 monthly) for unlimited users, unlimited mailboxes, and unlimited LinkedIn senders, with free Warmforge warm-up included.

Who Should Use Which Tool

No single tool wins for everyone. Here is how I'd sort the three by the job in front of you.

If you want to see how Salesforge stacks up against other tools, the comparisons hub has more, including Salesforge vs Mailshake and Instantly vs Salesforge. You can also read the full Forge Stack overview.

Final Verdict: Salesforge vs Saleshandy vs Mailshake

Saleshandy and Mailshake are both solid email-first tools, and each does its core job well. Saleshandy is an affordable, high-volume cold email platform with a dialer and a lead database, but it has no LinkedIn. Mailshake is a simple, per-seat sales engagement tool that gates LinkedIn and the dialer behind its $99/mo plan and offers no free trial. Neither one runs an autonomous AI SDR.

For real multi-channel B2B outbound, Salesforge is the stronger choice. At $80/mo for the Growth plan billed annually ($96/mo monthly), you get email and LinkedIn from one dashboard, unlimited users, unlimited LinkedIn senders, unlimited mailboxes, free Warmforge warm-up, and Primebox - a combination neither alternative offers at any price.

One falsifiable benchmark: UniteSync ran on Salesforge, Mailforge, and Warmforge to an 85.26% positive reply rate and a $2.86 CAC. The case study is public.

That is the kind of multi-channel outcome data the email-only tools can't show, because email-only tools don't run LinkedIn. Here is one more verified review from a long-term Salesforge user.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Salesforge better than Saleshandy or Mailshake?

For multi-channel B2B outbound, Salesforge is the stronger pick. It runs email and LinkedIn from one dashboard with unlimited mailboxes and no per-seat pricing, plus an optional AI SDR (Agent Frank). Saleshandy has no LinkedIn, and Mailshake gates LinkedIn to its $99/mo Sales Engagement plan. For pure high-volume cold email on a budget, Saleshandy is a reasonable alternative to consider.

What's the main difference between Salesforge, Saleshandy, and Mailshake?

Channels and pricing model. Salesforge runs email and LinkedIn natively with unlimited mailboxes on flat plans. Saleshandy is email plus a dialer and WhatsApp, with no LinkedIn, on flat plans. Mailshake is per-seat and adds LinkedIn and a phone dialer only on its $99/mo Sales Engagement plan. Salesforge is also the only one of the three with an autonomous AI SDR, Agent Frank.

Which is cheapest: Salesforge, Saleshandy, or Mailshake?

At the entry level they're close. Mailshake Starter and Saleshandy Outreach Starter both run $25/mo billed annually, and Salesforge Pro is $40/mo annual. Cheapest depends on scale, though: Mailshake charges per seat, so a team multiplies that number, while Salesforge Growth ($80/mo annual) covers unlimited users and unlimited LinkedIn senders on one flat plan. Saleshandy is cheapest for pure high-volume email.

Does Saleshandy support LinkedIn outreach?

No. Saleshandy's channels are email, a phone dialer, WhatsApp, and manual tasks. There is no LinkedIn automation built in. If LinkedIn is part of your motion, you'd run a separate LinkedIn tool alongside Saleshandy. Salesforge, by contrast, runs LinkedIn and email in the same sequence, with unlimited LinkedIn senders on the Growth plan.

Does Mailshake have an AI SDR?

No. Mailshake has SHAKEspeare, an AI email writer, and an AI Sales Coach, but both assist you rather than run campaigns on their own. Neither Mailshake nor Saleshandy offers an autonomous AI SDR. Salesforge's Agent Frank does: he prospects, writes, sends, follows up, and books meetings on Auto-Pilot or Co-Pilot. Agent Frank is a separate subscription from $499/mo billed quarterly.

Can I switch from Saleshandy or Mailshake to Salesforge easily?

Yes. Salesforge supports CSV upload and Google Sheets for contacts, connects unlimited mailboxes on every plan, and includes free Warmforge warm-up to keep new mailboxes healthy. You can bring your own domains or add Forge infrastructure (Mailforge, Infraforge, or Primeforge). A 14-day free trial lets you set up sequences before you commit to a plan.

Which tool has the best email deliverability?

All three include warm-up, so the gap is in the pool and infrastructure. Salesforge's Warmforge uses a curated pool of real Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 mailboxes with per-mailbox Heat Scores, free and unlimited on every plan. It also offers three dedicated infrastructure products to diversify sending. Saleshandy and Mailshake bundle warm-up but treat infrastructure as a single add-on.

Does Salesforge offer a free trial?

Yes. Salesforge has a 14-day free trial with no credit card required, and it includes email warm-up and unlimited mailbox connections during the trial. Saleshandy offers a 7-day free trial. Mailshake has no free trial and collects payment up front. Note that Agent Frank, the AI SDR, has no self-serve trial and requires a demo first.